Best Fantasy Board Games of 2024 – Review & Comparison

Without a doubt, there are classic fantasy board games that barely age and deserve the place amongst all-time greats. At the same time, some of the recent releases are shaking up the board game world, and you want to know about them.

Historically, the fantasy board game genre was born by a rapid expansion of the immensely successful fantasy role-playing game Dungeons & Dragons. The game was released in the 80’s and is still running strong. Since, board games have advanced significantly in their design, mechanics, and gameplay. On the other hand, the core of what makes an epic fantasy board game experience is still the same.

The definition of a good fantasy board game is free to interpretation and could mean different things for different people. For us, however, it goes back to the roots. It is an experience that is highly thematic, fictional and favors role-playing. Board games where players send their heroes on adventures, quests to explore deep dungeons and dark caverns crowded with exotic and evil creatures.

If this sounds like something you’ve been looking for – perfect! We have put an incredible effort cherry picking the best fantasy board games out there. We have considered different fantasy worlds, difficulty levels, player count, and game duration. In short, we are likely to have an excellent pick for you whatever your preference is.

Best Fantasy Board Games – Top 10 Comparison

1. Best Fantasy Board Game For Solo Play – Gloomhaven

Gloomhaven features a cooperative campaign mode consisting of 95 scenarios giving you over 200 hours of play time.

Players get to control fantasy characters completing scenario objectives and advancing in the overall campaign. Besides each character gets to accomplish personal quests. Completing hero quests grow your characters but make them exhausted at the same time.

You will find yourself changing characters multiple times through the lengthy campaigns. Characters age and retire making way for new characters to enter the play. It may feel strange at first, but if you think of your characters as mercenaries rather than heroes, it feels right.

Over time, we have learned to like it. It feels like an additional flair that helps to maintain a good level of engagement throughout the game.

There are 12 different character classes in the game. Each features a surprisingly unique playstyle and abilities which contribute to the already impressive replay value the game offers.

At the start of the round, each player chooses two cards to use in the given round. Selecting the right cards for the circumstances is the key to a successful round.

Overall, individual actions may feel essential, it is the team strategy that you want to keep coherent and efficient.

Getting the team alignment is more challenging than it may sound at first. Players are only allowed to communicate using general terms. You are not allowed to mention specific actions you are going to take or cards you are planning to use. It pushes the team coordination to a new level and gives a great bonding feel as your teamwork matures.

Unlike a typical dungeon crawler board games that feature dice for combat, Gloomhaven uses cards to resolve battles. They act as modifiers to the player’s attack values, items, and other player abilities. Overall, the change feels quite welcome and refreshing to the otherwise staid combat mechanic.

If you like cooperative boardgames with a fantasy theme, you will love Gloomhaven.  The concept of cooperative play is profoundly and firmly ingrained in everything you do in the game. Fighting monster, solving quests, coordinating rounds and even shaping the storyline, all done together in a joint team effort.

Moreover, Gloomhaven does a fantastic job on multiple fronts. As a result, in our other reviews, we have also nominated the game as one of the top coop board games and best RPG board games around.

2. Best Fantasy Board Game Dungeon Crawler – Descent: Journeys in the Dark

There you will find monsters to battle, riches to gain, and advance on your journey of stopping the overlord.

Depending on your gaming preference and the time available, Descent offers two ways of play. You can either play an individual quest or engage in a long-term commitment by playing a campaign.

Quests are broken down into two acts which take around an hour each to complete. Each quest has unique goals, both for heroes and the overlord. Also, the quest objectives are rarely plain or straightforward, such as kill all monsters in the dungeon. Most objectives are creative, thematic and tell a story in details. For example, you may need to save guests from a masquerade ball or steal some farmers crops if you are the overlord.

Campaigns typically represent multiple quests strung together. However, the quest sequence in campaigns is not always predetermined. Depending on the outcome of one quest and whether the heroes or the overlord wins, the next quest gets determined. It makes the gaming experience and storyline somewhat unpredictable and adds a nice element of surprise and a plot twist.

The fast pace is extremely important at successfully completing quests and winning campaigns. On your turn, you will find yourself presented with dozens of options most of which you would need to ignore as your heroes can only do so much before they get exhausted and require a rest. Part of the quest puzzle is picking the right battles to fight, doors to open and interactions to engage in. In fact, it feels that the time is your worst enemy and not the evil monsters spawned by the overlord.

Descent: Journeys in the Dark (Second Edition) provides an equally engaging, fun and enjoyable gaming experience for both heroes and the overlord. Unlike other dungeon crawler games, it supports an overlord character progression and allows the overlord to win quests too. Some quests, however, are inherently unbalanced, so it is important for the overlord player to adjust the gameplay difficulty for heroes to make it an enjoyable process for everyone.

The game comes in a box full of miniatures, cards, tokens, and tiles. Given that you have a good imagination, you should find all the pieces to build a custom adventure experience and develop your own storyline as you go.

Overall, the game brings to the table everything you would expect from a campaign-driven fantasy board game. It has character progression, amazingly crafted and unique quests delivering an intense gaming experience that sometimes comes down to a single roll of the dice. We have also nominated it among the top RPG games and dungeon crawler games to hit the market in one of our other reviews.

3. Best TV Series Fantasy Board Game – A Game of Thrones

The differences in resource availability, access to the sea, neighboring lands and stronghold locations cumulatively deliver an amazingly balanced and unique gaming experience every time. Given the location particularities and different special abilities for every house, the strategy and tactical play vary greatly making the game highly replayable.

Each game round consists of three phases – Westeros Phase, the Planning Phase and the Action Phase. During the first phase, the players need to work jointly to fight the Wildlings advance which carries detrimental effects for all players.

During the Planning phase, the players get to issue secret orders to their available units on the map. The orders may represent moving troops, attacking other player armies or strongholds, as well as mustering armies in preparation for the next round.

Lastly, the Action phase reveals and executes the players’ orders in sequence. At this time it is too late to react and you have limited options to counter something you have not seen coming. This, in essence, is the core of the game that makes it so intense, intriguing and frustrating at the same time.

The sense of intrigue, borderline paranoia is deeply built into the very fabric of the game that does an amazing job at breeding distrust between the players. There are no friends in A Game of Thrones and there is no one you can trust as being backstabbed, in most cases, is just a matter of time.

Overall, A Game of Thrones is an amazing experience of betrayal and deceit that encapsulates everything that makes George R.R. Martin’s books so enjoyable. If you do not take being manipulated, bashed, betrayed, ganged-up on or outwitted the wrong way, you are set for one of the best fantasy board games experience to have ever hit the table.

4. Best Adventure Board Game for Kids – Mice and Mystics

The gameplay is pretty straightforward as each turn consists of two parts – movement and action. Movement advances are determined by a dice roll, whereas the action is selected by the player and may represent an additional move, search, recover, attack or explore attempts.

The rules are easy to learn, and there is a great video tutorial from the publisher to help you start. You should find the rules to be simple enough for anyone who is eight years or older to grasp.

Although the game comes with some role-playing elements, it can only scratch that role-playing itch a little leaving hard-core RPG fans wanting more. At the same time, if you are after some light, perhaps family based fantasy experience that is full of thematic fun – Mice and Mystics ticks all the right boxes.

5. Best Fantasy War Board Game – Runewars

There are four distinct fantasy factions available in the game – humans, undead, elves, and chaos. Each faction features unique military units with special abilities and distinctive battle strategies.

The game runs for seven years where each time of the year (spring, summer, fall, and winter) represents a game round. A season-based event system adds an intriguing twist to the gameplay as each season either adds or removes a condition which can be used to strategic advantage (e.g. during winter, the water freezes and armies can walk on ice).

At the start of the game, each player gets a deck of eight order cards. Those cards represent the orders you can assign to your armies (e.g. attack, muster, gather resources, etc) at the start of each season. The cards are selected secretly by all players, which are then simultaneously revealed and sequentially executed. This order card placing mechanism is partially what makes Runewars epic. It adds suspense, uncertainty and even paranoia encouraging players to backstab and break alliances when your opponents expect it the least.

The other part of Runewars that makes it an epic fantasy war game is the armies and the combat system in general. Instead of dice, the game uses cards which are just as random, yet feel more innovative. Every time you muster army units, defend or attack, it feels epic. Battles are so engaging, intense and strategic that they become borderline addictive making you want to push your luck constantly, even against stronger opponents.

Besides, the game features heroes that play a supporting role dueling other heroes, completing quests or acquiring artifacts. The latter can provide an advantage during battles and can help to discover dragon runes. The distinctive feature of heroes is that they almost reside in a parallel dimension. They can freely move around the map without other player’s armies being able to cause any harm or impede them. They have personal agendas and nothing, but other heroes can stop them.

Through conquering lands, crushing opponents, destroying strongholds and completing hero quests, the players get to discover dragon runes. Once found, runes need to be carefully hidden and protected from other players as the player with the most runes at the end of the seventh year lands a victory.

6. Best Thematic Fantasy Board Game – Blood Rage

Whichever way you decide to score glory points, battles are inevitable and Blood Rage does a brilliant job at it. It features a dice-less combat system that uses cards to resolve conflicts. This does two things – makes battles more strategic and tactical in nature and removes the luck based dice rolls making the combat fair and slightly more predictable.

The combat system itself is surprisingly simple, yet tense and rewarding at the same time. It feels more of a mind game rather than a plain brute force clash. To resolve combats, players add combine the strength of their units with the action card that each player contributes face down. Most of the time, the cards would add an additional strength value to increase the chances of the combat success, yet bluffing approach is just as valid and extremely fun.

There are three types of cards to consider when drafting – battle, upgrade and quest cards. Battle cards typically allow you to have an advantage in combat by increasing strength or impeding your opponent’s actions. Upgrade cards provide special abilities, whereas quest cards help you with acquiring glory points so much needed to win the game and feast with Odin.

Most of the cards have references to different gods and you can prove your allegiance to that god by accumulating cards of that same type. It adds another layer of combat variety and strategy as special actions, bonuses, and additional glory points become available.

7. Best Fantasy Board Game For Two Players – BattleLore

The board consists of three sections – left flank, right flank, and the center. When players draw command cards, they specify the unit count and one of three sections of the board. For example, the command card may say ‘Order three units on the right’. That order allows the player to move three units in the right section of the map and initiate an attack.

The challenge is to apply command cards you have in your efficiently and timely. You need to optimize the overall offensive strategy for your entire army on all parts of the board. The timing and the order you play cards in is an absolute key to winning battles as well as the game.

Although the combat is essential in BattleLore, winning the game requires you to set your primary focus on unit positioning throughout the battle map. You want to make sure that your troops are occupying key locations that provide victory points, take advantage of the landscape or prepare you for the well times assault that can easily and quickly shift the balance of the game from one side to another.

Overall, it would be hard to go wrong with BattleLore, as it uses the same tried and tested card driven system that made light war games like Commands and Colours and Memoir ’44 so successful. Nicely made miniatures, a couple of added twists, an ability to custom build scenarios and a fantasy theme deliver a great package a very broad audience of players is sure to enjoy.

8. Best Family Fantasy Board Game – Small World

Over time, your race reaches its peak performance, which then starts to deteriorate forcing you to put the race into decline. You can always pick a new, energetic and ambitious race to continue your expansion, but timing is everything. In fact, knowing when and if to decline the race is critical to a good strategy and winning the game.

When picking a race, you also get to choose the superpower to go with it. Combining racial abilities and superpowers result in unique combinations that add a nice variety into the gameplay. For example, Ghouls race comes with a racial ability that allows them to remain in play after a decline. At the same time, the Hill superpower gains an additional victory point for every hill area under control. Combined, Ghouls remaining in play on Hill areas get to produce victory points.

A typical turn in the game is quite straightforward. First, players get to conquer new lands, then redeploy units and finally score points for lands they control.

The overly simplified unit advancement system does produce epic battles, yet delivers a fast-paced experience perfect for a getaway game.

After conquering lands, players can reposition units they control to prepare for the next turn. You typically want more units in areas of potential conflict and fewer units in safe territories. Just keep in mind to have a presence in all areas you control to score victory points for the round.

9. Best Fantasy World War Board Game – Chaos in the Old World

The gameplay is reasonably straightforward and takes around 15 minutes to learn. Each turn starts by drawing a Chaos card affecting the state of the Old World. The effects are typically temporary and only last throughout the current round.

Once the Chaos cards are resolved, the Summoning phase follows. During this phase, the gods get to spend their power points. You can choose to summon armies of demons for the upcoming battle or cast some deadly spells. With a few enticing options to choose from, spending points wisely create exciting dilemmas each turn.

Next, it is time to crush some rival armies that share the same region. Battles are optional and can be quite risky for most gods except probably Khorne. Cards can be played during battles to provide a significant battle advantage or constraint your opponents’ actions against you.

Lastly, it is time to mark the gods’ presence by spreading corruption in occupying religions. Cultists are essential at corrupting lands but are worthless in combat. Since each god has a distinct way of spreading corruption, cultist strategic placement is key. Given that most games are won through land corruption, protecting cultists is paramount.

Carefully thought out and balanced asymmetry coupled with an incredibly well-executed theme makes Chaos in the Old World a brilliant fantasy game. The board looks tight and feels busy as there is a lot going on. It makes you constantly check other players to see what are they up to and how are they tracking on their way to one of the four win conditions.

With so much happening on the board, you would think that the game should be a lot more complicated and take hours to play, but the game is surprisingly simple and can be enjoyed in well under two hours. Learning the basic game mechanics should take you 15 minutes and then you are off to experience a great fantasy game that deserves a place in any board gamer’s collection.

10. Best Adventure Board Game – Legends of Andor

Rounds in the game are represented by days. At the beginning of each day, players get to take actions measured in hours (i.e., action points). Once the player is out of hours, the day ends. Alternatively, you can push your character to do up to three more hours a day. Depending on the circumstances, it may be a viable option, but it is important not to overuse it. Pushing your characters makes them tired and loses willpower which is essential when fighting monsters.

Each time the day ends or the monster dies, the narrator pawn advances on the narrative track. Advancements reveal new legend cards that tell the essential part of the scenario puzzle and add twists to the storyline. This system makes the gameplay intriguing and fun. On the other hand, playing the same scenario for the second time is a lot less rewarding.

Although there is a healthy portion of battles to be had in the game, the combat mechanism is straightforward.  Dice and different modifiers are used to determine the overall strength value and resolve battles. The opponent who ends up having a higher strength value wins the battle. It is that simple.

The key, however, is picking the right battles to fight. Killing too many monsters advances the narrative quicker leaving you less time to complete the objectives. On the other side, not killing enough could see them overrun the castle and end the game.

Player interaction and cooperation is what drives Legends of Andor. As a team, you get to decide which quests to do, who does it and jointly balance the time track. The latter poses the biggest challenge of the game. You want to ensure you can complete the objective in time but not let the monsters overrun you.

The game is also extremely family-friendly as it is cooperative, fun, engaging and easy to play. If you are looking for one of the best fantasy board games for a great family evening, Legends of Andor is worth checking out.

Frequently Asked Questions